Is Travertine Pink or Yellow?

Last week I flew to Houston to help a client (in the middle of her renovation) with a colour dilemma.

Before she called me, she had interviewed 3 designers and the local paint store consultant had also been to her house to talk about colour.

Photo by Maria Killam (We tweaked the exterior colour too, more on that soon)

All but one confirmed that pinky beige (specifically Sherwin Williams Kilim Beige 6106-on the left with the molding attached to the bottom) was the best colour to go with the porcelain travertine that she had chosen (below).

Travertine with 3 paint colours

This caused her great concern because she was clear that ‘pinky beige’ was not going to work with her furniture. Prior to my arrival, she had shown the tile to three different people. One said, “I see gray”, one said “I see red” and another said, “I see beige”.

And the scariest part was that all three were correct, but which colour would be right for the walls, and also work with her furniture? Should her cabinets be French walnut or painted, what colour should the countertop be? How would we create flow throughout the rest of the house?

Travertine generally has a lot of pink in it (above photo from a magazine) and when she took me to another house in Tanglewood (Joni, I was this close to you) that her builder was finishing, every room had been painted a lighter or darker version of pinky beige (probably the same strip right next to Kilim Beige).

This is not the way to create flow in your house by the way—taking one colour and going from light to dark.

She had also tested this colour (which was also Sherwin Williams but I can’t remember the name of it now); it was very close to BM HC-35 Powell Buff. You can see that this colour also works with the tile and I confirmed that it was perfect for the main areas of her house!

When she took me to the showroom to see what it looked like installed, I held up my paint chip of HC-35 to the walls in the store and it was an exact match. This was a total coincidence but it was great for her to see that it was the perfect shade to go with the travertine in her home.

It also proves that our instincts are many times accurate but when it’s not our area of expertise it’s too easy to second guess ourselves.

Image from Cote de Texas

Joni from Cote de Texas just posted this Chateau in Charlotte, North Carolina on her blog and she wrote that she loves stone floors because of the sense of permanence they add to a home and I agree!

I now understand her obsession with French design because that’s Houston. Everything there is French inspired and many of the homes are like a French chateau!

The woodwork and detail is extraordinary (we don’t have anything like this in Vancouver). Look at that staircase (above)!! So beautiful!

Photo by Maria Killam

I snapped this photo (above) when I was in Paris 3 years ago. I remember the clerk giving me the hairy eyeball because I so obviously looked like a tourist—instead of a real shopper– in my comfortable shoes and backpack. The one in the previous image is way more beautiful in my opinion!

Image from Cote de Texas

Here’s another image from Joni’s post! Look at the ceiling, isn’t that colour gorgeous? It’s not the ‘real french blue’ (apparently there’s a real name for ‘french blue’ if anyone knows what it is please post a comment), but I found out exactly which colour it is on my trip. Stayed tuned for that in my next post!

And what happened with my client? Well I miss her already, we immediately became friends! It was a whirlwind—almost 2 days—we picked out fabrics for drapery and bedding, tile for the bathrooms, and it was all wrapped up in the colours we had chosen for her 5,000 square foot home! We are also using the green in the chairs below and some other blues and golds.

Image from Cote de Texas

Travertine is so huge in European influenced design, I have come to the conclusion (especially after this trip) that travertine is like jeans, it goes with a lot of different colours but I’m guessing the French aren’t that fussed that it’s got a lot of pink in it. Just like in Europe they don’t care that the area rugs match the decor, it’s the same with travertine!

What do you think? Do you agree with my theory?

Need help choosing the right neutral or colour?  My How to Choose Paint Colours: It’s all in the Undertones ebook takes the hundreds of choices down to 9 neutral undertones along with list of all my other go-to best grays, broken down into 3 undertones, green, blue and purple. The beige undertones of pink, yellow, green, gold, orange and taupe along with the best greens and blues. 

My bonus book of  colours is worth the price of the ebook alone but you will also get my system of understanding undertones so you can stop making mistakes when sourcing tile, carpet, countertops, etc.

The only way to choose the right colour every time is to combine my system of understanding undertones with the most indispensable colour tool available. You can purchase your own set of my curated large colour board collections here.

If you would like to transform the way you see colour, become a True Colour Expert.

Related posts:

Does your Home have Colour Flow? Take the Toss Cushion Test.

How to Know if the Tile you have selected has the Right Undertones

10 Things I learned from my Designer; by a Happy Client


If you are new to this blog, click here to see the Best of Colour Me Happy

While you’re here, subscribe to this feed so you don’t miss out!

Shares 42


leave aREPLY

  1. Looking at the pic of the three paint smaples, my eye went directly to the one on the right. It appeared seamless with the floor. Having lived in Houston for 20 years and now Oklahoma, I am beginning to think our lighting wants yellow tones! Or it could be the influence of our resident designer, Charles Faudree! Thanks for all the fabulous information!

  2. Kimberly Grigg - Knotting Hill Interiors

    Maria, thank you for your insightful blog about travertine. As a fellow designer, who stares at colors everyday, in search of that "perfect shade" for each design challenge, I find great inspiration in your blogs. It's amazing how a fresh analogy or a new perspective can truly add focus – or an interesting twist! – to almost any design project. Your blog is not only interesting, but it is also quite entertaining (i.e., "the hairy eyeball" haha)! Yours is one of my very favorite blogs! Thanks for sharing!

  3. Hmmm…I always thought of it more yellow ar even light gold. But depending on where it comes from and the lot, it could also have pink tones. I can see why a client would have you come to the states….choosing paint for this situation could send the average person into therapy!

  4. Wow, how cool that you went down to Texas for a design job!!

    It looks like you picked a great colour to work with the travertine tile. Having lived with a pinky kitchen for 8 years, I'm sure your client would NOT have liked it if her house was painted pinky beige to match the tiles. It's just not a happy colour.

    Hope you'll post some pictures of this house when the decorating is all done 🙂


  5. Kelly, Arte Styling

    What a fun adventure that must have been, flying off to Texas for a 2 day design consult! Good thing she brought you in because why-oh-why would that Kilim Beige be recommended for her home with those floor tiles? If the paint question was "Which paint looks most like the floor tile?" then Kilim Beige is the answer. In the photo, they look exactly the same. But wall color selection should not be made based predominantly on what MATCHES a material. Wall colors need to create the right mood for a space…and usually they need to contrast the floor color, not be its twin.
    The color you helped your client select is much warmer, therefore it creates a "happier" mood…and creates a nice contrast to the grey and pink undertones in the travertine. I bet your client was thrilled to know that she wasn't crazy, despite what all the other color "experts" said.

  6. I almost always agree with you, Maria. After all, you're the expert. I specifically chose the travertine in our hall bath because of all the yellow in it. The soft blue on the walls compliments it beautifully I think. But your more trained eye may see something different. We were thinking of installing the same travertine in our master, but I'm changing my mind about it now that I am considering a carrera marble countertop.

    I think you are right about another term for French blue. It's on the tip of my brain. Hope someone thinks of it so I can put it to rest.

    ~ Victoria

  7. And I'm with poster Nancy. If I had known you were coming to Texas, I would have paid for you to come to the Dallas area to consult too.

  8. When I read this post I thought, great, one day when I'm looking for tiles I'll know something about travertine.

    Little did I know that this information would come in handy with coffee tables. I'm searching for a coffee table and found one with a travertine top. Since I now know that travertine has a pink undertone I knew right away that it wouldn't work.

    Thanks again Maria. It would have been a big mistake if I had bought the table.

  9. The french use a copper based solution to paint their shutters and doors…can't find the reason why or what it is called.

    As for that elusive french blue/gray/green, they call it tendre gris. It morphs from blue to green with a gray in there somewhere. Anyone know of a paint color that does this?

  10. Materials that consist of multiple colors can be tricky to navigate!! It’s a similar situation to trying to find a paint color that can unite a pinky-beige sofa with golden-beige carpet (how many times has that come up?).
    I agree that lighting is quite influential, it can dictate how much color saturation a room can accommodate. I also like using colors that are complex or full-spectrum. This means they have multiple pigments in the formulation, so the is color of the paint connects to all the different flavors of the travertine, whether it’s pink, gray, beige or gold.

  11. Maria

    I had a travertine fireplace surround installed in travertine, and was disappointed in the look – you say that clean trumps dirty colors and I agree. My travertine looks dingy and it was very hard to select a wall color. I ended up with SW lotus pod and painted the mantel SW Sable.
    The room is on the North side of the house which does not help. If I had a do over I would have picked a cleaner color for the tile (something other than travertine), a cleaner wall color and achieved a fresher look. I may try repainting the mantel in cream to see if that wakes up the room a bit.

  12. I am so glad I found your blog, if not simply for the reassurance that I’m not crazy to notice undertones (not saying I’m not crazy in other ways, lol). I don’t always recognize what is wrong or how to fix it, but I notice. My builder special home offered 5 carpet choices in addition to travertine tile. After it was installed, I realized that when making my choices, I made the mistake of looking directly down on the samples, rather than at an angle (as you typically see it across a room). Since none of the other carpet samples seemed to work, I picked the one I thought best. After installation, though, it was abundantly clear the carpet and tile did NOT work and I couldn’t find one shade of paint to go with both (open floor plan). I wound up picking two similar but different tones of paint, using one against the carpeted walls and the other where there was tile. I understand now it was the undertone I was seeing. Most people couldn’t tell the difference, but I could. It worked, but I agonized over the decision, painted multiple paint boards, and am still not sure I did the right thing (I don’t live there anymore). I score a 100% on the FM 100 hue color vision test (as I’m sure you would, Maria). It’s a test used, in part, for those who classify diamonds based on their subtle differences in clarity and color. It must be strictly administered under specific lighting conditions, so the online version is not as stringent, therefore easier to pass…still a starting point, though. The test also highlights those who are going to be hypersensitive to color. Training to recognize color nuances clearly helps fine tune the existing ability. I fear, though, that many in the industries associated with selecting color aren’t self aware enough to recognize their own visual limitations and are spreading color mistakes faster than they can be corrected. Soooo glad you’re trying!!! Every time I hear it’s “close enough”, I wonder whether it’s a lack of physical ability, a difference in taste, or an “I don’t care enough to get it right” attitude. Regardless, I find myself asking, “OMG, why would they pick THAT?! Sorry, my very long way of saying thank you!